Cover: Law’s Quandary, from Harvard University PressCover: Law’s Quandary in PAPERBACK

Law’s Quandary

Add to Cart

Product Details


$37.00 • £29.95 • €33.50

ISBN 9780674025738

Publication Date: 09/30/2007


222 pages

6-1/8 x 9-1/4 inches


Smith takes us on a lively, thought-provoking romp through the philosophy of law.—Antonin Scalia, First Things

Smith argues that there is an ontological gap between prevalent legal theories and legal practice. He is concerned that the realist and pragmatic approaches of Holmes, Llewellyn, Fuller, and, later, Posner refuse to acknowledge the metaphysical component of law. He proceeds to demonstrate persuasively that words, statutes, and judicial decisions alone cannot account for common assumptions and behavior in the everyday practice of law. He concludes that efforts to ‘squirm’ out of ‘the Law’ as a metaphysical force have failed. Having illustrated the continuing gap between practice and theory, the author examines how meaning might be attributed to the law. He rejects the idea that meaning is created by the interpreter or reader. There are various ways of positing the author of a law, but a law’s meaning flows from the intentions of its enactor, however conceived. Smith concludes that the classical belief in a metaphysical presence behind the law remains alive, although circumspectly submerged, in the practice of law today. This is a timely, down-to-earth critique of those who have rejected the possibility of functioning legal principles beyond the day-to-day decisions and practice of law.—R. Heineman, Choice

Ordinary people assume that legal terms like freedom of speech have some real or true meaning. Most important legal theorists say there is no such thing. It is not unheard of for the sophisticated classes to reach conclusions at odds with common sense. But this creates a real problem for the stability of our legal system. Smith explores this quandary in a way that is wonderfully clear, honest, and funny. This is the best book I have read in several years.—John H. Garvey, Dean, Boston College Law School, author of What Are Freedoms For?

Smith’s treatment of the issues he addresses is outstanding. His discussion is consistently probing, thoughtful, and imaginative. Smith’s range of reference is impressively broad—yet I never had the sense that he was trying to impress. His clarity—aided by his wonderfully engaging, and occasionally humorous, conversational style—is exemplary. But the enviable clarity/accessibility of Smith’s writing should not obscure just how penetrating—I am tempted to say, brilliant—his commentary is. It may sound faintly ridiculous to say this, but I thought that this book was a jurisprudential page turner.—Michael J. Perry, Emory University School of Law, author of Under God? Religious Faith and Liberal Democracy

Recent News

Black lives matter. Black voices matter. A statement from HUP »

From Our Blog

logo of the MacArthur Foundation

Nicole Fleetwood and Monica Muñoz Martinez Awarded MacArthur Fellowships

Harvard University Press congratulates its authors Nicole Fleetwood and Monica Muñoz Martinez for being named to the 2021 class of 25 MacArthur Fellows. The prestigious no-strings-attached $625,000 awards are given to individuals “who have shown extraordinary originality and dedication in their creative pursuits and a marked capacity for self-direction.”